On Spector's bar recursion
نویسندگان
چکیده
We show that Spector’s “restricted” form of bar recursion is sufficient (over system T ) to define Spector’s search functional. This new result is then used to show that Spector’s restricted form of bar recursion is in fact as general as the supposedly more general form of bar recursion. Given that these two forms of bar recursion correspond to the (explicitly controlled) iterated products of selection function and quantifiers, it follows that this iterated product of selection functions is T -equivalent to the corresponding iterated product of quantifiers.
منابع مشابه
Understanding and Using Spector's Bar Recursive Interpretation of Classical Analysis
This note reexamines Spector’s remarkable computational interpretation of full classical analysis. Spector’s interpretation makes use of a rather abstruse recursion schema, so-called bar recursion, used to interpret the double negation shift DNS. In this note bar recursion is presented as a generalisation of a simpler primitive recursive functional needed for the interpretation of a finite (int...
متن کاملA Short Note on Spector's Proof of Consistency of Analysis
In 1962, Clifford Spector gave a consistency proof of analysis using so-called bar recursors. His paper extends an interpretation of arithmetic given by Kurt Gödel in 1958. Spector’s proof relies crucially on the interpretation of the so-called (numerical) double negation shift principle. The argument for the interpretation is ad hoc. On the other hand, William Howard gave in 1968 a very natura...
متن کاملModified bar recursion
We introduce a variant of Spector’s bar recursion (called “modified bar recursion”) in finite types to give a realizability interpretation of the classical axiom of countable choice allowing for the extraction of witnesses from proofs of Σ1 formulas in classical analysis. As a second application of modified bar recursion we present a bar recursive definition of the fan functional. Moreover, we ...
متن کاملThe equivalence of bar recursion and open recursion
Several extensions of Gödel’s system T with new forms of recursion have been designed for the purpose of giving a computational interpretation to classical analysis. One can organise many of these extensions into two groups: those based on bar recursion, which include Spector’s original bar recursion, modified bar recursion and the more recent products of selections functions, or those based on...
متن کاملOn Bar Recursion and Choice in a Classical Setting
We show how Modified Bar-Recursion, a variant of Spector’sBar-Recursion due to Berger and Oliva can be used to realize the Axiomof Choice in Parigot’s Lambda-Mu-calculus, a direct-style language forthe representation and evaluation of classical proofs.We rely on Hyland-Ong innocent games. They provide a model to per-form the usual infinitary reasoning on Bar-Recursion needed...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
- Math. Log. Q.
دوره 58 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2012